Author = Sahabi, Bahram

Examining the Equity Premium Puzzle in Iran: A Practical Approach Using a Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium Model

Volume 23, Issue 90, Autumn 2023, Pages 175-217

https://doi.org/10.22054/joer.2024.76901.1171

Sahar Zare Joneghani, Bahram Sahabi, Hassan Heydari, Mehdi Zolfaghari

Abstract  The equity premium is obtained from the difference between the return on the risky stock asset and the return on the risk-free asset; the failure of financial theory to explain high equity premium is known as the equity premium puzzle. This puzzle was introduced for the first time by Mehra and Prescott in the framework of the C-CAPM model and states that stock returns are so high that it cannot be explained by the fluctuation of real consumption growth. Therefore, the examination of the puzzle is important because it provides the basis for the correction of models that lead to failure when faced with financial data. The purpose of the present study is to investigate the equity premium puzzle in Iran. Focusing on the relationship between the real and financial sectors, this study has specified a DSGE model in accordance with the conditions of Iran's economy. The specified model can investigate the equity premium puzzle in Iran by applying technology shocks, government spending, oil revenue, stock price index shock and money supply and the effect of these shocks on asset returns and consumption. The results show that the productivity shock, oil income shock and stock price shock in the high-risk aversion parameter while smoothing the consumption and creating a high equity premium can explain the equity premium puzzle in Iran. Introduction The neoclassical growth model is among the most successful models that have been influential in representing business cycles and macroeconomic issues, but it faces challenges when it comes to financial data. One of the best examples of this challenge is the equity premium puzzle presented by Mehra and Prescott (1985). Using the C-CAPM model, they showed that the empirical equity premium is larger than the risk tolerance in the standard neoclassical models of financial economics; therefore, the equity premium puzzle provided a basis for modifying the standard neoclassical models. So far, various studies have been carried out to modify the model, which provided solutions to solve the Equity premium puzzle. Some studies solved the Equity premium puzzle by introducing economic recession as a state variable (such as the study of Campbell & Cochrane (1999)), Others evaluated the Equity premium puzzle by including consumption habits (such as Constantinides (1990)); Epstein and Zin (1991) also looked for the Equity premium puzzle by separating the relative risk aversion coefficient and the time discount rate. In Iran, research has been done by Mohammadzadeh et al. (2015) and Erfani et al. (2015). By making changes in the C-CAPM model, they evaluated the Equity premium puzzle in Iran. Among the weaknesses of these studies, we can mention the neglect of the connection between the real and financial sectors, as well as the lack of attention to the role of fluctuations in macroeconomic variables in investors' decisions. In this regard, the present study has tried to correct these weaknesses by designing a dynamic stochastic general equilibrium (DSGE) model for the Iranian economy. To be more precise, the purpose of this model is to examine the equity premium puzzle in a more realistic way, because it examines the fluctuations of asset returns and consumption in response to the shocks introduced in the model. The main idea of this model is taken from the study of Kaszab and Marsal (2015). Methods and Material The data used in this study are quarterly data (from the first quarter of 1993 to the fourth quarter of 2021) adjusted gross domestic product without oil (minus net exports), oil income, consumer price index, private sector consumption, private investment, monetary base, government spending, stock price index, and the bank deposit rate. The data were collected from the Central Bank of Iran and the Tehran Stock Exchange Organization. The specified DSGE model is simulated using MATLAB software and the Diner program. Results and Discussion As mentioned, this study specified the DSGE model with the approach of modifying preferences and focusing on the relationship between the real and financial sectors. The specified model includes 4 sections: household, corporations, financial, and monetary policymakers. The equations obtained from the first-order optimization conditions were linearized by the Uhlig method. The constant weighted ratios were calculated according to the data of Iran's economy and some parameters were calibrated using previous studies, and finally, 2 criteria were used to evaluate the simulated model in MATLAB: The closeness of the mean and standard deviation of the theoretical variables resulting from calibration to the mean and standard deviation of the real-world variables. The adaptation of the response of the variables to the shocks applied to the model with the theoretical topics. In table (3), the first criterion has been evaluated: Table 1. Comparison of mean and standard deviation of simulated variables and real data The standard deviation Average Title simulated value real data simulated value real data 0.0274 0.0895 0.00000 0.0000 inflation 0.0547 0.0938 0.00000 0.0000 Private investment 0.0251 0.0319 0.00000 0.0000 Private consumption 0.0785 0.2072 0.00000 0.0000 Stock price index 0.0050 0.0763 0.00000 0.0000 Bank deposit rate Source: Research calculations. According to the above table, the mean and standard deviation of the simulated variables of the model and the real sample are relatively similar, which reflects the relative ability of the model to predict the fluctuations of the variables. Evaluation of the second criterion (analysis of immediate response): In the present study, in order to investigate Iran's equity premium puzzle in the form of the DSGE model, taking into account the fact that changes in consumption depend on the preferences of individuals, which is reflected in the intertemporal elasticity of substitution of consumption; the instantaneous response functions of the simulated variables have been investigated in 3 different values of the risk aversion parameter. The values of this parameter are reported in Table 4: Table 2. Relative risk aversion coefficient values   The first model, the second model the third model Risk aversion parameter 1.65 5.00 12.00   the coefficient value is less than the acceptable range the coefficient value is within the acceptable range The coefficient value is greater than the acceptable range Technology shock: Table 3. Response functions of simulated variables to technology shock Source: Research calculations According to Table (5), in the higher risk aversion parameter (12), a negative correlation between inflation and consumption and a positive correlation between consumption and real stock price index can produce higher positive equity premium and confirm the equity premium puzzle in Iran in short-run, medium-run, and long-run. Money supply shock: Table 4. Response functions of the simulated variables to the money supply shock Source: Research calculations Money supply shock in higher risk aversion parameter (12), in the short run (up to 4 periods) can explain the equity premium puzzle in Iran.     Government expenditure shock: Table 5. Response functions of the simulated variables to the government expenditure shock  Source: Research calculations The shock of government spending in all values of the risk aversion parameter, by creating a positive covariance between consumption and inflation, produces a negative premium for 9 periods and produces a small positive premium from the 9th period until reaching a stable point; therefore, government expenditure shock cannot explain the equity premium puzzle.     Oil income shock: Table 6. Response functions of the simulated variables to the oil income shock Source: Research calculations According to Table (8), in the higher value of the risk aversion coefficient, more premium is produced, which can explain the equity premium puzzle.     Stock price shock: Table 7. Response functions of simulated variables to stock price shock Source: Research calculations This shock can show the equity premium puzzle in the short-run, medium-run, and long-run by producing a positive premium in the value of the high-risk aversion coefficient. Conclusion The aim of the present study is to investigate the equity premium puzzle in Iran. Focusing on the relationship between the real and financial sectors, this study specified a DSGE model in accordance with the conditions of Iran's economy; the specified model, assuming that households have sufficient information about the values of risk aversion parameters and consumption habits, was able to solve the Equity premium puzzle in Iran by applying technology shocks, government spending, oil income, stock price index, money supply and the effect of these shocks on asset returns and consumption. The results showed that in the value of the risk aversion parameter higher than the acceptable range, consumption has fewer fluctuations (the reason is the existence of consumption habits). Therefore, since households do not like sudden changes in consumption, then with changes in labor supply, saving or purchasing assets without risk. The analysis also reveals that when oil income, stock price, and technology shocks impact the risk aversion parameter beyond an acceptable range, a high equity premium emerges in the short, medium, and long term. This elevated equity premium helps explain the equity premium puzzle. Based on these findings, two policy recommendations are suggested for policymakers: Focus on Structural Parameters: Policymakers should consider structural parameters such as consumption habits and risk aversion, as households are aware of these values. Neglecting these factors may adversely affect policy objectives by misaligning with household expectations. Leverage the Equity Premium as an Investment Incentive: A high equity premium can encourage investment in riskier assets over risk-free assets under uncertain conditions. While a high premium may help mitigate investor uncertainty and risk aversion, it is essential for policymakers to implement economic programs that minimize fluctuations in macroeconomic indicators and control societal uncertainty. These considerations underscore the importance of stability in economic policy to support both investment confidence and broader economic goals.

Estimation of Health Costs of Electricity Production in Iran

Volume 18, Issue 70, Autumn 2018, Pages 23-52

https://doi.org/10.22054/joer.2018.9559

Mohammadbagher Asadi, hosein sadeghi soghdel, Bahram Sahabi, alireza naseri

Abstract By supplying energy for many activities, electricity is one of the most important drivers of industrial development. But, electricity industry is one of the largest producers of polluting gases due to combustion of fossil fuels. This has raised serious concerns about the externalities of pollutant emissions in power generation processes. This paper aims at modeling and estimating the health effects and costs of electricity generation in thermal power plants in Iran based on the Impact Pathway Approach using SimPacts software. Based on our results, the health costs of electricity generation in Iran in year 2014 are more than 110 trillion Rials, which accounts for about 1 percent of GDP in this year. Also, the research results show that combined cycle and gas turbine power plants respectively impose the lowest and highest social health costs per kilowatt-hour of electricity generation. Ultimately, by modifying the fuel mix and only using natural gas as the fuel for power plants, the health costs of electricity generation will be reduced by more than 53 percent.

Analyzing the Effects of Power Plant Fuel Price Reform on Iran Electricity Market by Using Agent-Based Simulation

Volume 17, Issue 65, Summer 2017, Pages 81-114

https://doi.org/10.22054/joer.2017.7847

Mohammadbagher Asadi, hosein sadeghi soghdel, Bahram Sahabi, alireza naseri

Abstract  
This paper examines the impacts of fuel price reform on the technology mix of power plants and other outputs of the Iran electricity market. In this regard, Iran electricity market has been simulated by using an agent-based model for a long-term period. Then, as a result of fuel price reform, the changes in the outputs of the electricity market, including the average price, average efficiency, capacity and technology mix of generation has been studied and analyzed. The results show that, the current situation of technology mix of power plants is far from optimum conditions. Accordingly, the reform of fuel prices may change the returns and incentives of investment in different technologies so that, technology mix of power plants would face major changes, and by increasing share of more efficient power plants like combined cycle power plants, the average efficiency of electricity production increase from current 36% to more than 55%.

Speculation Effects on Inflation in Iran Economy: TVP-FAVAR Model

Volume 15, Issue 57, Summer 2015, Pages 193-228

Mohsen Khezri, Bahram Sahabi, Kazem Yavari, Hassan Heydari

Abstract Given the importance of inflation in Iran economy, scrutiny of inflation determinants is important .according to various studies, evaluation of determinants of inflation using standard VAR model, may lead to wrong conclusions and this is due to omitted variables bias in VAR model. For example, the problem of price puzzle in the empirical literature is one of these results. In this study, for a more accurate assessment of determinants of inflation in Iranian economy and forecasting inflation, instead of using FAVAR model with constant coefficients, we have employed TVP-FAVAR models and inflation has been modeled. In this model, the variables of GDP growth, growth of the monetary base, inflation, exchange rates and interest rates are considered as the main variables, and to estimate the non-observable variables of speculation section return, variables in the overall classification are modeled. Based on the results, the relationship between the variables change over time and conditions prevailing in the economy is effective on the influence of model variables on each other.
 

The study of Factors Affecting the Export of Services Case study: Export of Technical and Engineering Services

Volume 12, Issue 47, Winter 2013, Pages 1-20

Khaled Ahmadzadeh, Kazem Yavari, Abbas Assari Arani, Bahram Sahabi

Abstract In recent decades and especially in developing countries, the trade of services has faced an increasing trend. The export of services can improve trade balance, economic growth, employment as well as development of merchandise sector. This paper uses a descriptive and analytical approach and intends to evaluate performance and factors affecting the total export of services and particularly the export of technical and engineering services in OIC selected countries by applying panel data method. The results of estimating the performance indicators and comparative advantage of technical and engineering services export indicate that between years 1994 to 2010, Iran's position among these countries has improved. In our analysis, factors such as GDP per capita, real effective exchange rates, inflow of foreign investments, communication infrastructures and also being member of two trade blocs -ECO and D8- have significant and positive effect on the total export of services and also the export of engineering services. Thus, it is necessity for governmental institutions and private sector in Iran to plan and prepare to further develop the export of services.